Clscs 430R: THE RISE AND FALL OF ATHENS
Winter 1996
MWF 2-2:50 p.m.
Course Description: More than any other city-state in Greece, fifth century Athens exemplifies the apogee of Greek civilization. This semester Classics 430R will study the history of Athens from 509 B.C., the year of Kleisthenes’ "democratic" reforms, through Athens’ period of strength and empire until her fall at the hands of Sparta in 404 B.C. Accordingly the seminar will cover the Persian Wars, the development of the Athenian Empire, and the Peloponnesian War. Any of these three areas could, on its own, form the basis of a serious graduate course; taken together, however, these periods of Athenian history will provide a case study of the "organic" phases of a state’s rise and fall as well as providing a fuller history of Sparta’s animosity towards Athens and a comprehensive view of Persia’s critical role and the beginning and end of the Fifth Century.
This course will focus on issues of constutional development, inter-state relations, and military and political history while not neglecting cultural developments. Significant attention will be given to source issues and criticism: primary literary texts and other documents (in translation) form the core of our study, allowing for significant discussion regarding the developing genre of Greek historiography and for an introduction to the proper use of epigraphy.
Texts: The following texts are available in the B.Y.U. Bookstore and will be used regularly throughout the class:
Green, Peter. The Year of Salamis. London: Widenfeld and Nicolson, 1970. [packet]
Kagan, Donald. The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, 1969.
Meiggs, Russell. The Athenian Empire. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1972.
Plutarch. The Rise and Fall of Athens. Nine Greek Lives. Trans. Ian Scott-Kilvert. New York: Penguin Books, 1960.
Bradley, Pamela. Ancient Greece. Using Evidence. Edited by David Patterson. Caufield East Victoria: Edward Arnold (Australia), 1988.
Burn, A. R. Persia and the Greeks. Second Edition. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1984.
Bury, J.B. and Meiggs, Russell. A History of Greece to the Death of Alexander the Great. Fourth Edition. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1975, repr. 1985.
Diodorus. Diodorus of Sicily. Translated by C.H. Oldfather (Loeb Classical Library, Diodorus vols IV-VI). Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1946-1954.
How W. W. and Wells, J. A Commentary on Herodotus. 2 volumes. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1912
--------. The Peace of Nicias and the Sicilian Expedition. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1981.
--------. The Fall of the Athenian Empire. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1987.
de Ste. Croix, G.E.M. The Origins of the Peloponnesian War. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1972.
Traill, John S. The Political Organization of Attica; a Study of the Demes, Trittyes, and Phylai, and Their Representation in the Athenian Council. Princeton, N.J.: American School of Classical Studies at Athens, 1975.
Xenophon. Hellenica I-IV. Trans. Carleton L. Brownson (Loeb Classical Library) Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1918.
ATL Meritt, B.D., Wade-Gery, H.T., and McGregor, M.F. The Athenian Tribute Lists. 4 vols. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1939-53.
Davies, APF Davies, John Kenyon. Athenian Propertied Families, 600-300 B.C. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1971.
Fornara, ABG Fornara, Charles W. The Athenian Board of Generals from 501 to 404. Wiesbaden, F. Steiner, 1971.
FGH Jacoby, Felix. Die Fragmente der griechischen Historiker. Berlin and Leiden 1923-
Hill, Sources2 Sources for Greek History. Between the Persian and the Peloponnesian Wars. Collected and arranged by G. F. Hill. Revised by R. Meiggs and A. Andrewes. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1951.
IG Inscriptiones Graecae. Berlin, 1873-- Vol. I, I2 (1924), I3 (199?). Inscriptiones Atticae Anno Euclidis Vetustiores
ML Meigg, Russell and Lewis, David. A Selection of Greek Historical Inscriptions to the End of the Fifth Century B.C. Rev. ed. Oxford: Clarendon; New York: Oxford University Press, 1988, c1969.
OCD Oxford Classical Dictionary. Edited by N.G.L. Hammond and H.H. Scullard. Second Edition. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1970.
RE Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft. Edited by G. Wissowa et al. Stuttgart: J.B. Metzlersche Verlagsbuchhandlung, 1893-1978.
Requirements: Clscs 430 is a topical senior seminar, and each meeting presupposes the preparation and participation of the students. All readings should be completed before class except for the rare instances when particularly heavy assignments prompt the instructor to divide the secondary readings among the class members. Students are also responsible for material presented by classmates in reports (see following paragraph).
Seminar participants should come to class prepared to discuss and argue the evidence and positions held for each day’s topic. Each student will give two oral presentations, each lasting approximately 20 minutes and accompanied by a handout and a select bibliography. In most cases the report topics listed in the syllabus provide initial bibliography as a starting point. A substantial paper is due on the last day of class, and in most cases it will be a further development of one of the student’s two oral reports. In addition there will be midterm and final examinations.
Grades will be calculated by the following formula:
Midterm Examination 20%
Final Examination 25%
Class Schedule
M08Jan
Course Introduction and Review of Texts
W10Jan
Period Sources
Introductions to the Penguin editions of Herodotus, Thucydides, and Plutarch
Hignett, 25-40
Meiggs, 1-18
Epigraphic Sources; Reference Works, Tour of BYU’s Ancient Studies Room
Fornara, v-vii, xix-xxii
Martin Luther King Holiday; NO CLASS
W17Jan
Archaic Athens (Review)
[Arist.] Ath. Pol. [1]-12
Hdt. 5.55-71 (Penguin, 360-64, 366)
Th. 6.54-9 (Penguin, 443-446)
Bury, 115-132
See also: Plut. Vit. Sol; Bradley, 78-91; Hignett, Constitution, II-IV
Reforms of Kleisthenes (Review)
[Arist.] Ath. Pol. 17-22, 41-69
Hdt. 5.66-75, 6.123 (Penguin, 364-68, 431-32)
Bury, 134-140.
Hignett, Constitution, VI
D.M. Lewis, "Kleisthenes and Attika," Historia [D51.A5] 12 (1963), 22-40.
Persia and the Greeks
Fornara nos. 34-35, 45-46
Green, 3-10
Hignett, Invasion, 78-86
Ionian Revolt
Hdt. 1.141-216, 5.97-6.47 (Penguin, 379-404)
Burn, 193-217
F26Jan
Marathon
Hdt. 6.94-140 (Penguin, 421-439)
Burn, 221-227, 236-256
Green, 27-40
Meiggs, 30-32
Xerxes and the Invasion
See also: Diod. 11.1-3
The Hellenic League
Fornara nos. 52, 56
Green, 80-108
Hignett, Invasion, 96-104
See also: Diod. 11.5
Themistokles
Fornara no. 55
Green, 22-27
Thermopylai
Plut. Vit. Them. 7
Green, 109-143
See also: Diod. 11.5-11
Artemesion
Hdt. 8.1-39 (Penguin 525-537)
Plut. Vit. Them. 8-9
Green, 143-149
Hignett, Invasion,149-192
See also: Diod. 11.12-13
F09Feb
Salamis
Fornara no. 21
Green, 153-198
Hignett, Invasion, 193-239
Winter of 480/79
Hignett, Invasion, 240-247, 264-273
W14Feb
Plataia and Mykale
Fornara nos. 57-60
Hdt. 9.1-113 (Penguin 577-621)
Plut. Vit. Arist. 11-22
Green, 228-283
Hignett, 247-263, 273-288
F16Feb
Sestos and Byzantion
Fornara no. 61
Hdt. 9.114-122 (Penguin, 621-624)
Th. 1.89-96, 128-135
Plut. Vit. Them. 19-21; Vit. Arist. 23
Burn, 550-558
Green, 283-287
Kagan, Outbreak, 31-40
Meiggs, 32-41
See also: Diod. 11.41-46.3, 64-59
M19Feb
PRESIDENT’S DAY HOLIDAY; no class
Tu20Feb
TUESDAY IS MONDAY!
The Delian League
Hdt. 9.106, 114 (Penguin, 618, 621-622)
Plut. Vit. Arist. 24-25, Cim. 4-6
Kagan, Outbreak, 40-44
Meiggs, 42-67, 459-464
de Ste. Croix, 298-307
Report: The "Peloponnesian League": Kagan, Outbreak, 9-30; de Ste. Croix, 101-150, 339-342.
The Pentekontaëtia
Fornara nos. 62, 65
Th. 1.97-101, 135-138
Diod. 11.60-62
Kagan, Outbreak, 44-48
Report: Athenian Cleruchies and the "Corn Route": A. Graham, Colony and Mother City (Chicago: Ares, 1963, repr. 1971), 166-192. T.S. Noonan, "The Grain Trade of the Northern Black Sea in Antiquity," AJPh 94 (1973) 231-242.
Ephilates and the Radical Democracy
Fornara no. 67
Plut. Vit. Cim. 15-17; Vit. Per. 3-10
Meiggs, 88-91
Land Empire and Egypt
Fornara nos. 72, 74, 77-80, 8, 109
Plut. Vit. Per. 11, 14-16
Meiggs, 92-108
Overextension and Collapse
Fornara nos. 71, 76, 85, 94, 95
Plut. Vit. Cim. 18-19
Meiggs, 109-151
The Thirty Years’ Peace
Fornara no. 97
Diod. 12.5-7, 22, 26.2
Plut. Vit. Cim. 13.4-5; Vit. Per. 12-13, 17-18, 21-23
Kagan, Outbreak, 109-130
Meiggs, 152-188
Report: Coinage Decree: H.B. Mattingly, "The Athenian Coinage Decree," Historia (1961) 148-188; E.S.G. Robison, "The Athenian Currency Decree and the Coinage of the Allies," Hesperia Suppl. 8 (1949) 324-340.
MIDTERM EXAM
W06Mar
The Revolt of Samos
Fornara nos. 111, 113, 115
Th. 1.115-117
Plut. Vit. Per. 24-28
Kagan, Outbreak, 170-178
F08Mar
The Administration of Empire
Fornara nos. 99, 102-103, 107
Tribute and the Fruits of Empire
War Causes I: Epidamnos, Kerkyra, and Potidaia
Fornara no. 126
See also: Diod. 12.30-34
War Causes II: Megara and Sparta
Th. 1.66-88, 118-125, 139-146
Report: The Megarian Decrees: B. McDonald, "The Megarian Decree," Historia 32 (1983) 385-410; de Ste. Croix, Origins, 225-289.
The Beginning of the Archidamian War
Th. 2
Plut. Vit. Per. 33-39
Kagan, AW, 17-123
Fornara no. 131
Kagan, AW, 124-186
Meiggs, 311-323
See also: Diod. 12.55-59; H.D. Westlake, "The Commons at Mytilene," Historia 25 (1976) 429-40.
Demosthenes and the "Aggressive" Policies of 426-425
Th. 3.103-4.57
Plut. Vit. Nic. 1-8
Kagan, AW, 187-259
See also: Diod. 12.60-63
The Tribute Reassesment of 425
Meiggs, 324-339
Sicilian Stirrings; Brasidas and Amphipolis
Th. 4.58-135, 6.1-7
Kagan, AW, 260-304
H.D. Westlake, "Thucydides and The Fall of Amphipolis," Hermes 90 (1962) 276-87
See also: Diod. 12.66-73.
The Peace of Nikias
Plut. Vit. Nic. 9-10
Kagan, AW, 305-349; PNSE, 19-77 (skim 78-155)
Meiggs, 340-350
Report: The Siege of Melos: M. Amit, "The Melian Dialogue and History," Athenaeum 46 (1968) 216-235; A. Maria van Erp Taalman Kip, "Euripides and Melos," Mnemosyne 40 (1987) 414-419; J.R. Grant, "A Note on the Tone of Greek Diplomacy," CR 15 (1965) 265-6; H.L. Hudson-Williams, "Conventional Forms of Debate and the Melian Dialogue," AJPh 71 (1950) 156-169; C.W. Macleod, "Form and Meaning in the Melian Dialogue," Historia 23 (1974) 385-400.
The Sicilian Expedition
Th. 6.8-53, 60-105; 7.1-87
Plut. Vit. Nic. 11-30; Alc. 13-23 (skim 1-12)
Kagan, PNSE, 157-209, 329-353 (skim 210-328)
See also: Diod. 12.83-84; 13.1-33
The Ionian and Decelean Wars; The Four Hundred at Athens
Fornara nos. 148-153, 156
Plut. Vit. Alc. 24-31
Kagan, FAE, 1-50 (skim 51-105)
Return and Fall of Alcibiades
Fornara, no. 159
Kagan, FAE, 274-324
Meiggs, 354-373
See also: P.A. "Thucydides and Alcibiades," REG 65 (1952) 59-96.
Lysandros and the Fall of Athens
Xen. Hell. 2.1.1-2.2.23
Diod. 13.104-107
Plut Vit. Alc. 35-39; Vit. Lys. 6-15
Kagan, FAE, 376-412
Meiggs, 373-374.
Papers Due by 5:00 p.m.
Tu23Apr
11:00 a.m.-2:00 p.m.
FINAL EXAMINATION
Select Bibliography
In addition to the standard texts listed at the top of the syllabus, also see the bibliographies in Hignett’s Xerxes’ Invasion of Greece, Meiggs’ Athenian Empire, and Kagan’s four works on the period. The following selection of articles is deemed particularly important for any further study beyond this course.
Andrewes, A. "The Arginousai Trial," Phoenix 28 (1974) 112-22.
--------. "Thucydides on the Causes of the Peloponnesian War," Classical Quarterly n.s. 9 (1959) 223-239.
Boer, W. den. "Themistokles in Fifth Century Historiography," Mnemosyne 15 (1962) 225-237.
Bradeen, D.W. "The Athenian Casualty Lists," Classical Quarterly 19 (1969) 145-59.
--------. "The Popularity of the Athenian Empire." Historia 9 (1960) 257-269.
Bridges, A.B. "The Athenian Treaty With Samos, ML 56," Journal of Hellenic Studies 100 (1980) 185-8.
Brunt, P.A. "The Hellenic League Against Persia" Historia 2 (1953-4) 135-163.
--------. "Thucydides and Alcibiades," Revue des études grecques 65 (1952) 59-96.
Buck, R.J. The Athenian Domination of Boeotia," Classical Philology 65 (1972) 217-227.
Burn, A.R. "Thermopylae and Callidromus," in Studies Presented to David Moore Robinson (St. Louis, 1951) 1.480-9.
Chambers, M. "The Significance of the Themistokles Decree," Philologus 111 (1967) 157-69.
Cole, J.R. "Cimon’s Dismissal, Ephialtes’ Revolution, and the Peloponnesian Wars," Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies 15 (1974) 369-85.
--------. "Studies in the Athenian Tribute Lists. II," Classical Philology 38 (1943) 129-134.
Evans, J.A.S. "The Final Problem at Thermopylae," Greek, Roman, and Byzantine Studies 5 (1964) 231-7.
Ferguson, W.S. "The Constitution of Theramenes," Classical Philology 21 (1926) 72-75.
--------. "The Oligarchical Movement at Athens," Cambridge Ancient History (1940) 321-347.
Fornara, C.W. "On the Chronology of the Samian War," Journal of Hellenic Studies 99 (1979) 7-17.
--------. "The Value of the Themistokles Decree," American Historical Review 73 (1967) 425-33.
Gomme, A.W. "Thucydides ii 13,3" Historia 2 (1953-4) 1-21; Historical Commentary on Thucydides, 432-6.
--------. "Two Notes on the Athenian Tribute Lists," Classical Review 54 (1940) 65-69.
Hammond, N.G.L. "The Battle of Salamis," Journal of Hellenic Studies 76 (1956) 32-54.
--------."The Campaign and Battle of Marathon," Journal of Hellenic Studies 88 (1968) 13-57.
--------. "Origin and Nature of the Athenian Alliance," Journal of Hellenic Studies 87 (1967) 41-61.
Hansen, M.H. "The Number of Athenian Hoplites in 431 B.C." Symbolae Osloenses 56 (1981) 19-32.
Holladay, Journal of Hellenic Studies 109 (1980) 176-82.
Jackson, H.W. "The Original Purpose of the Delian League," Historia 18 (1969) 12-16.
Knight, W.F.J. "The Defence of the Acropolis and the Panic Before Salamis," Journal of Hellenic Studies 51 (1931) 174-8.
Lenardon, R.J. "The Chronology of Themistokles’ Ostracism and Exile," Historia 8 (1959) 23-48.
Littman, R.J. and M.L. "The Athenian Plague: Smallpox," Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association 100 (1969) 261-75.
Marr, J.L. "Andocides’ Part in the Mysteries and the Hermae Affairs, 415 B.C.," Classical Quarterly n.s. 21 (1971) 326-338.
--------. "Athenian Finance in the Peloponnesian War," Bulletin de correspondence hellénique 92 (1968) 450-84.
--------. "The Growth of Athenian Imperialism," Historia 12 (1963) 257-73.
--------. "The Peace of Kallias," Historia 14 (1965) 273-81.
McGregor, M.F. "The Politics of the Historian Thucydides," Phoenix 10 (1956) 93-102.
Merrit. B.D. "The Early Athenian Tribute Lists," Classical Philology 38 (1943) 223-239.
Oliver, J.H. "The Peace of Kallias and the Pontic Expedition of Pericles," Historia 6 (1957) 254-5.
O’Neil, J.L. "The Exile of Themistokles and Democracy in the Peloponnese," Classical Quarterly n.s. 31 (1981) 335-46.
Page, D.L. "Thucydides’ Description of the Great Plague at Athens," Classical Quarterly n.s. 3 (1953) 97-119.
Plekt, H.W. "Thasos and the Popularity of the Athenian Empire." Historia 12 (1963) 70-77.
Poole, J.C.F. and Holladay, A.J. "Thucydides and the Plague of Athens," Classical Quarterly n.s. 29 (1979) 282-300.
Pritchett, "New Light on Thermopylai," American Journal of Archaeology 62 (1958)
Raubitschek, "The Case Against Alcibiades (Andocides IV)," Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association 79 (1948) 191-210.
Rhodes, P.J. "The Five Thousand in the Athenian Revolution of 411 B.C." Journal of Hellenic Studies 92 (1972) 115-127.
Scranton, R.L. "The Fortifications of Athens at the Beginning of the Peloponnesian War," American Journal of Archaeology 42 (1938) 526-36.
de Ste. Croix, G.E.M. "The Constitution of the Five Thousand," Historia 5 (1956) 1-23.
de Ste. Croix, G.E.M. "The Character of the Athenian Empire." Historia 3 (1954/5) 1-41.
Stockton, D. "The Death of Ephialtes," Classical Quarterly n.s. 32 (1982) 227-8.
Stockton, D. "The Peace of Kallias," Historia 8 (1959) 61-79.
Westlake, H.D. "The Commons at Mytilene," Historia 25 (1976) 429-40.
--------. "Thucydides and the Pentecontaetia," Classical Quarterly n.s. 5 (1955) 53-67.